Compare

Vouch is a credential broker – it turns a hardware key tap into short-lived credentials for SSH, AWS, GitHub, Docker, and more. It is not a secrets manager, a PAM tool, or a full identity platform. This page compares Vouch to six adjacent tools: AWS IAM Identity Center, HashiCorp Vault, 1Password SSH Agent, Teleport, Beyond Identity, and Ory.

Feature matrix

When to choose Vouch

Choose Vouch when:

• You want a single authentication event (one YubiKey tap) to cover AWS, SSH, GitHub, Docker, package registries, databases, and the Claude and OpenAI APIs.
• You want every credential to be hardware-backed and phishing-resistant by default, not as an optional add-on.
• You are a small-to-medium team (2–50 people) and do not want to operate Vault or Teleport infrastructure.
• Your team uses Google Workspace or Microsoft Entra ID and you want organizational identity federated into AWS without setting up IAM Identity Center.

When to choose something else

AWS IAM Identity Center

Choose IAM Identity Center when:

• You only need access to AWS services. Identity Center credentials also work with ECR, CodeCommit, CodeArtifact, and RDS IAM auth through standard AWS CLI steps – what it lacks is SSH certificates, GitHub tokens, and non-AWS registries.
• You manage permission sets across multiple AWS accounts in an AWS Organization.
• You want a fully AWS-managed solution with no third-party dependencies.

HashiCorp Vault

Choose Vault when:

• You need a secrets manager for application secrets (API keys, database passwords, encryption keys) in addition to developer credentials.
• You need dynamic secrets for databases, cloud providers, and PKI beyond what Vouch covers.
• You have a platform team that can operate and maintain a Vault cluster.

Vouch and Vault solve different problems. Vouch brokers developer credentials (human-to-service). Vault manages application secrets (service-to-service). The two are complementary.

1Password SSH Agent

Choose 1Password when:

• You only need SSH key management and your team already uses 1Password.
• You do not need AWS, GitHub, Docker, or other integrations.
• Hardware keys are not a requirement.

Teleport

Choose Teleport when:

• You need a full privileged access management (PAM) solution with session recording, access requests, and approval workflows.
• You need to broker access to Kubernetes, databases, internal web applications, and Windows desktops – all through a unified access plane.
• You have a platform team that can operate Teleport (self-hosted) or budget for Teleport Cloud.

Beyond Identity

Choose Beyond Identity when:

• You need passwordless authentication for workforce identity across SaaS applications.
• You need device trust and posture checks deeply integrated into SaaS application authentication (Vouch now supports device posture policies for developer credential issuance, but Beyond Identity focuses on broader workforce SSO).
• Developer credentials (AWS, SSH, GitHub) are not a primary concern.

Ory

Choose Ory when:

• You want to build or operate a full identity platform for your own applications, including user registration, login, OAuth/OIDC, passkeys, permissions, or an identity-aware proxy.
• You need self-hostable identity infrastructure and have the engineering capacity to wire it into your application stack.
• Developer credential brokering (AWS, SSH, GitHub, Docker, package registries) is not the primary problem you are solving.

Vouch is not…

• A secrets manager. Vouch does not store or distribute application secrets. Use Vault, AWS Secrets Manager, or similar tools for that.
• A PAM tool. Vouch does not provide session recording, access request workflows, or just-in-time access escalation. Use Teleport or CyberArk for that.
• A password manager. Vouch does not manage website passwords or form-fill credentials. Use 1Password, Bitwarden, or similar tools for that.
• An identity provider. Vouch delegates authentication to your existing IdP (Google Workspace, Okta, etc.) and acts as a credential broker, not a source of identity.